Sigmund Freud, who is theoretician
and the father of psychoanalysis, was a Viennese doctor and clinician. He made
numerous studies on child development and according to them, children go
through a series of psychosexual stages which lead to the development of the
adult personality. These stages are the Oral Stage, which comprises the first
year of a baby’s life, the Anal Stage, the Phallic Stage, the Latent Stage, and
the Genital Stage. In the Oral Stage, babies are totally and necessarily depend
on their mothers because they fulfill the basic needs of the baby such as
bathing, feeding or wiping. As a result of this, the baby moves from a state of
unpleasant biological need to satiated biological satisfaction. At this point,
Freud thought that the dependency of babies on their mothers was about the
indispensable function of the mother in the baby’s life. But he interpreted
these essential needs as physical needs. This interpretation didn't consider
the importance of a mother’s touch on a baby and led to the acceptance of the
attachment theory instead of the dependency theory in the coming years.
The psychologists who
justify attachment theory believe that the power of the caregiver’s touch is as
important as the basic needs of babies and it has a significant influence on
child development. In the 1950s, Harry Harlow made an experiment on rhesus
monkeys to contribute to the importance of caregiving, affection, and social
relationships in life. He separated infant monkeys from their mothers
a few hours after
birth; he put the infants in a place where there were
two kinds of surrogate
monkey mother machines which dispensed milk and one of the machine monkeys was covered with a soft
terry cloth. Then,
he put the monkeys in a room with the machines to see their preference. Infant
monkeys chose the monkey with the soft terry cloth and milk. Therewithal,
Harlow made a critical difference in the experiment to understand the necessity
of attachment; he equipped one of the monkey machines just with milk while
another machine was covered with a soft terry cloth. At this point, the
responses of monkeys clearly indicated the significance of attachment in
development. The result
of the second experiment was astonishing. The monkeys preferred the monkey
machine which was covered with soft cloth even though the other monkey machine
had milk which is a requisite for his life. Consequently, psychologists and
doctors accepted the importance of attachment. With this in mind, the
experiment has been judged by some people because of its ethical issues.
This experiment proved that
the orphanage system has harmful effects on the child’s development and needs to be
changed. Today, most of the countries are encouraging adoption instead of the
orphanage system and
children become healthier physically and mentally.
In 1944, American
psychologists made an unethical experiment to see the results of the shortage
of attachment on humans. In order to do that, they used 20 new-born
infants. During the experiment, doctors, and psychologists fulfilled the main
needs of babies. They fed the babies sufficiently, gave them a comfortable
place to sleep and kept their bodies clean. However, they didn't contact the
babies directly to prevent the sense of feeling. In order to do that, they used
plastic gloves if they had to touch them. Psychologists were planning to
continue this experiment for two years but just after 4 months, unexpected
outcomes compelled them to interrupt the experiment: the babies started to die.
Before the death of the babies, experimenters observed that the babies were
becoming unresponsive to the person who fulfilled their needs in contrast to
their response at the beginning of the experiment; they weren't crying at all.
The experimenters tried to bring the babies back
to life by touching. Unfortunately, it didn't work.
As a result of this experiment,
psychologists accepted the necessity of attachment and interpreted this need as
an essential factor in babies’ life. Therewithal, the unethical side of the
experiment has been judged by many people but the reason for the applicability
of the experiment was about the conditions in those days; the experiment was
made during the Second World War and the babies were probably obtained in
return for money.
In conclusion,
the importance and necessity of attachment is accepted, and it has been proved
that the results of the deficiency of attachment on babies can lead to serious
issues in an individual’s life. Today, many psychologists have experienced this
situation in many cases. Through these experiences and experiments, we have
learned that we are not depending on our caregivers just because they satisfy our
needs, we develop an emotional relationship , and need them as humans.
SUEDA DİNÇ
.