There are various interrogation techniques to retrieve
the requested information. One of them is torture, which is the severe infliction of emotional and
physical pain or suffering, and it is done to get compliance from an individual
whether it is to get a confession, admission, and information or not. According
to UN laws, torture is the only crime that every state must punish, no
matter who commits it or where. It is argued that torture is justified because
it is a necessary technique to achieve requested goals whereas the others think
that torture is unacceptable in any case since it is inhumane and degrading treatment.
Firstly, proponents of torture claim that
information can matter a lot, which leads soldiers or the police to feel they have a
right to torture when they suspect an individual of breaking the laws. People
advocating torture think that torture is an advanced interrogation technique
that is far more effective than others, and the information can be easily extracted
from individuals. However, opponents of torture argue that in fact, torture is
not guaranteed to be useful in producing accurate information since people will
say or admit anything to avoid being tortured,
so the information they provide is unreliable anyway.
Lastly, proponents of torture assert that in
case of emergencies, torture should be implemented to preserve public peace and
security. For instance, if a person becomes a threat to public safety, he or
she should be immediately arrested, so that officials can effortlessly learn what
they want to do in society via various methods of torture like water boarding,
mock executions, and so forth. Nevertheless, nobody has the right to
deliberately harm other human beings with the intention of causing physical and emotional pain although they have committed a major crime because people
who undergo torture are adversely affected by the experience throughout their
whole lives. This is also a crime, and there isn't a person who deserves brutal
torture in the world.
In conclusion, whether torture is justified or not
is a controversial issue because of a variety of clashing views. However, when
it is considered from a humanitarian point of view, it does serious harm to
people, and no government has a right to restrict people's right to life.
Torture is not a solution to anything. Accordingly, torture should never
be practiced for any reason.
No comments:
Post a Comment